Welcome to Original #1 Brothers Pizza
At Original #1 Brothers Pizza, the essence of authentic New York-style pizza comes to life in Peoria, AZ. Established with a passion for delivering genuine flavors, this eatery has quickly become a local favorite, celebrated for its generous combo specials and welcoming atmosphere. Patrons rave about the classic pepperoni pizza, crispy wings, and delightful mozzarella sticks, all served alongside refreshing pitchers of beer and lemonade. The spacious booths are perfect for families and friends, fostering a community vibe. With exceptional service that thrives even during busy times, Original #1 Brothers Pizza promises not just a meal, but a memorable dining experience that keeps customers returning.
-
7440 W Cactus Rd # A15, Peoria, AZ 85381, United States Hotline: +1 623-486-4111
Welcome to Original #1 Brothers Pizza, where the fragrant aroma of authentic New York-style pizza fills the air, inviting you into a world of flavor and nostalgia. Located conveniently at 7440 W Cactus Rd # A15, Peoria, AZ 85381, this gem of a restaurant has quickly made a name for itself among pizza enthusiasts and families alike.
Original #1 Brothers Pizza is not just about great food; it's about creating memorable moments. With their extensive menu featuring a variety of combo specials—including delectable pizzas, wings, and refreshing pitchers of beer and lemonade—every visit feels like a celebration. The ambiance is warm and inviting, with spacious booths that comfortably accommodate families and groups, making it a perfect spot for post-escape room challenges or casual hangouts.
- Customer Favorites: From classic pepperoni to well-done ricotta and sausage pies, there's something that will remind you of home. Reviews consistently praise the authenticity and taste, with one patron stating that it’s the closest they’ve found to their New York roots.
- Delicious Combinations: Guests rave about trying out combinations like BBQ/hot wings alongside mozzarella sticks, showcasing the fantastic variety and value offered.
- Exceptional Service: The restaurant’s commitment to customer satisfaction shines through. Patrons have highlighted the speed of service and the warm demeanor of the staff, ensuring that your dining experience is as pleasant as the food is delicious.
- Affordability: With such a diverse menu and reasonable pricing, many customers have expressed their amazement at the value they receive. One reviewer noted a total of just $70 for a meal shared among four, making it a budget-friendly outing without compromising quality.
The vibrant atmosphere complemented by classic background music brings a sense of joy, establishing Original #1 Brothers Pizza not just as a place to eat, but as a place to gather and create lasting memories. One customer mentioned how the restaurant turned around a challenging day, highlighting the power of great service and delicious food to lift spirits.
With numerous glowing reviews affirming its standing as the best pizza place in town, Original #1 Brothers Pizza is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic New York-style pizza in Peoria. Whether you're a local or just passing through, be prepared to find your new go-to pizza joint. After all, there’s no better place to indulge in fantastic food served with a smile!
For inquiries or to place an order, reach them at +1 623-486-4111. Dive into a slice of happiness today at Original #1 Brothers Pizza!
Stopped by after escape room challenge, perfect spot and across the parking lot so just a short walking distance. They have so many combo specials, pizza, wings, pitcher options. We tried out the classic: Pepperoni pizza Bbq/hot wings mozzarella sticks Pitcher of beer Pitcher of lemonade House salad Nostalgia at its best, background music dear Delilah! Large big booths, perfect for groups and families! Lots of space, very clean good food Price's incredible! Our total was 70 split 4 ways 18 a person Great value and variety Wood definitely would cone back after the escape room again! Service was amazing, very courageous and super speedy!
My sister and I are from NY and we always order a large pie with ricotta and sausage, well done. Comes out perfect, sometimes not as well done but still great! It's the closest to our home town pizza place that we can find out here. And we've tried the hype of the NY pizza places from tiktok .... Original #1 brothers is definitely still better. Highly recommend. One day maybe we'll try something else too.
Really delicious and authentic New York style pizza. Absolutely loved it and plan to make this my go-to pizza joint.
Best pizza place in town. I will continue to support this pizza place along with spreading the word to family and friends on how great the food is here and atmosphere
These guys are awesome. Delicious pizza. Fantastic crust. Lunch specials with wings and a slice are super reasonable and delicious. Love this place.
All around great experience. Food, service, & atmosphere. Will definitely be back!
I was not having a great day yesterday. I had tried to order wings from another local spot and due to both long wait times and terrible customer service I ended up at Original #1 Brothers Pizza. I know that lots of places were busy yesterday with the superbowl but the staff here seemed to be enjoying the rush. There was a line when I walked in (they are busy and I had had trouble getting through by phone) but the line moved very quickly and I was greeted with a smile at the counter. I placed my order and it was ready much quicker than any other restaurant had quoted me and even quicker than the lovely gentleman at the counter had quoted me as well. They saved dinner for my family and cheered me up as well. I will not be back to Long Wong's anytime soon. They were incredibly rude even though I was understanding about the busy day their attitude was enough to make me take my business somewhere else. I'm so glad that I did. #1 Brother's will be where I come in the future. My wings were huge, hot and delicious and honestly a bright spot in a less than stellar day thanks to their amazing customer service!
This is the best pizza in town! The service is great and the guys at the front counter are very kind and personable. The waitresses are very tenative and kind as well. We eat here every Friday night unless we are our of town.